How Does A Business Owner Value Their Company for Shareholder Protection?

Valuing a company for any reason, including for Shareholder Protection, can be tricky. There’s no tried and tested method of doing it. Moreover, each business differs, even within the same industry. However, there are a few guidelines an adviser will use to help value your business when it comes to Shareholder Protection Insurance. For example, we’ll look at: Your company’s cashflow Your company’s profits, i.e. whether they’re static or increasing Multiples of net profit plus cash in bank and assets (better for companies with a solid, longstanding financial history) Intangible factors, for instance the company’s reputation and relationship with clients. Ultimately, different industries / sectors often command different values, even if underlying business metrics are similar. As an independent insurance broker we have in-house experts who can provide advice in this area if you need help.

Is Shareholder Protection a Benefit in Kind / P11D?

Whether or not premiums are a P11D / benefit in kind for shareholders depends on how you set up the shareholder protection insurance policy. In brief: On a life of another basis — HMRC does not typically consider premiums a P11D benefit On a company share purchase basis — HMRC does not typically consider premiums a P11D benefit Own life under business trust — depends on whether the business pays or the individual pays, with HMRC considering it a P11D / benefit in kind where the business pays for the shareholders but not if the shareholder pays themselves.

Is Shareholder Protection Tax Deductible?

The tax position of Shareholder Protection Insurance depends on which of the three ways you choose to set it up. In some cases premiums may be a tax deductible business expense against your corporation tax bill. This is common where the benefit passes the wholly and exclusively test, which means it’s entirely for the benefit of the business. In this case, HMRC typically allows premiums as a business expense where the business pays for them. However, if the benefit is not wholly and exclusively for the benefit of the business, such as where the payout benefits shareholders, HMRC usually does not consider premiums as a tax deductible business expense. It’s a tricky area where it’s best to get expert advice.

What is a Cross Option Agreement?

You set up cross option agreements alongside Shareholder Insurance. It ensures that, if a shareholder dies, the other shareholders have the option to buy the deceased’s shares (the ‘call’ option). It also provides the option for the deceased’s family to sell (the ‘put’ option). This is also known as a double option agreement. If a shareholder suffers a critical illness rather than passing away, only the put option exists. This gives the critically ill shareholder the option to sell their company shares to the other business owners but not the right for the business to buy the shares. This protects a shareholder absent through illness from being forced out of the company and is also known as a single option agreement. It’s essential that your company’s articles of association give each party the option to buy / sell the shares, not an obligation. An obligation could result in an inheritance tax bill as it may disqualify the shares from business property relief (BPR). If in doubt, seek legal advice.

Shareholder Protection Insurance

Get My Instant Quotes

4.9 / 5
Rated 4.92 / 5 by 3115 client reviews

Tom ConnerDirector

T: 01273646484

24-07-2021

Shareholder Protection Insurance is a form of business life insurance that covers you, your business and your shareholders. It pays out a lump sum if a shareholder dies or suffers a critical illness.

This lump sum offers the necessary funds for the surviving shareholders to buy back the deceased or critically ill shareholder’s stake in the company.

More than half of businesses have no formal shareholder agreement about what would happen if a business owner died. How would your company cope?

What Does It Cover?

If a shareholder dies or suffers a terminal illness (where a doctor diagnoses them with less than 12 months to live), a Shareholder Protection policy pays out a lump sum. The surviving shareholders use this to purchase the shares of the deceased shareholder.

It makes succession planning for your company as smooth as possible, allowing the company to continue trading as normal. Meanwhile, it is a safety net for the deceased shareholder’s family members who are able to realise the value of their business interest.

What About Critical Illness Cover?

You can include Critical Illness Cover in your shareholder protection insurance policy. This will also pay out if any of the business partners becomes critically ill. The three most common claims are for:

Cancer
Heart attacks
Strokes.

However, in addition to the ‘big three’ conditions, Critical Illness Insurance also covers anywhere between 10 to 100+ illnesses. This includes Parkinson’s, multiple sclerosis (MS), permanent loss of vision / hearing, loss of limbs and motor neurone disease.

Samantha Haffenden-Angear, Independent Protection Expert at Drewberry

If you plan on including Critical Illness make sure you compare providers carefully.

Look beyond the number of illnesses the policy covers and examine the definitions of these conditions. It’s these definitions that determine your ability to claim for a condition.

Samantha Haffenden-Angear
Business Protection Expert at Drewberry

Why Is Director Shareholder Protection Insurance Important?

Research from Legal & General shows…

Half of businesses have no shareholder agreement on what would happen if a business owner dies or suffers a critical illness.
43% of limited companies have not reviewed their articles of association in the last year.
37% of businesses said the surviving shareholders would want to purchase the shares of an absent shareholder to keep control of the company. However, most have no clear way to fund this.

What Happens Without Shareholder Protection Insurance?

If you or one of your business partners dies without deciding what will happen to your share in the business, it will likely pass to your estate. If so, a family has two alternatives. They can take over the deceased’s position as a partner or sell the share.

As you can imagine, neither of these avenues is problem-free. Consequences include:

Losing control of the business

If family members take over the deceased’s position as shareholder, there’s no guarantee they can make a contribution to the business. Their presence could even be bad for the company if they don’t have the skills to run a business.

Gaining a sleeping partner

Similarly, the family member could become a sleeping partner who doesn’t help run the company but is entitled to a share of the profits. Also, the family member may be unhappy if they have no control over the direction of a business they rely on for income.

Selling to an unwelcome party

The family members could sell their interest, leaving the remaining partners working as minority shareholders with an unwelcome new partner. Or if there are no natural buyers, both the family and the company could face financial problems.

CLIENT SUCCESS STORY 🥳
David and Graham own Interface NRM and chose Shareholder Protection as a safety net to ensure their families, the business and their staff would be ok should something happen to them. Full story →

What About Keyman Insurance and Relevant Life Cover?

There are other forms of business insurance which might be more appropriate if there is little intrinsic value in the business and no need for director Shareholder Protection Insurance.

What Is Key Person Insurance?

Keyman insurance pays out a lump sum to the business should a key individual suffer a critical illness or die. The individual does not need to be a shareholder and the funds are used to maintain business continuity.

It is usually more appropriate for start-ups or companies where there is limited shareholder value. Read why start-up Bikmo chose Keyman Insurance here →

What Is Relevant Life Cover?

Relevant Life Insurance is popular with company directors paying out a tax free cash lump sum to their loved ones should they die.

There are savings to be had of up to 50% on personal life insurance premiums.

How Much Does Shareholder Protection Insurance Cost?

The monthly cost of Shareholder Protection Insurance depends on your needs and circumstances. There are policy factors to take into account, such as the:

Sum assured or level of cover
Length of the policy term
Decision as to whether to add Critical Illness Cover.

There are also personal factors to consider. This means the cost of cover varies from shareholder to shareholder. For instance, insurers will price cover for each individual based on their:

Age
Medical history / state of health
Smoker status
Lifestyle / participation in hazardous activities.

Average Monthly Policy Premiums

In the table below, we’ve used our instant online calculator to compare Shareholder Protection Insurance quotes from the best UK insurers in the market.

Each life insurance premium is for a healthy non-smoker seeking £150,000 of level cover as a fixed payout over 10 years.

Age	Monthly Cost of Cover
Shareholder Protection Premiums: Life Insurance Only
35 Years Old	£7.10
45 Years Old	£12.66
55 Years Old	£26.78
Shareholder Protection Premiums: Life & Critical Illness Cover
35 Years Old	£32.56
45 Years Old	£72.21
55 Years Old	£158.57

Compare Top 10 UK Business Insurers

Takes approx. 60 seconds

4.9 / 5
Rated 4.92 / 5 by 3115 client reviews

How Does HMRC Tax Shareholder Protection?

How HMRC taxes Shareholder Protection Insurance depends on several factors. One of the most important is the wholly and exclusively test. This decides whether the policy is entirely for the benefit of the firm and plays a big part in how HMRC taxes premiums and the payout.

However, HMRC may tax premiums and / or the payout — this is largely based on how you purchase cover. You have three ways to buy Shareholder Protection Insurance:

On a life of another basis
On a company share purchase basis
Own life under business trust.

Each option has its own tax rules. Which one is right for you and your company depends on your circumstances.

IMPORTANT NOTICE 🧐
Tax rules are dependent on your circumstances and are subject to change. Drewberry does not offer tax advice. Take appropriate advice from your accountant and / or solicitor.

Life of Another

The simplest option.
Each shareholder pays for a policy personally on the life of their fellow shareholders. You each pay from post-tax income, so there’s no tax concerns for the company.
As each individual gets the life insurance payout to purchase the shares, this generally means there’s no tax for the firm to pay on the benefit, either.
However, it’s only really viable with no more than three shareholders. This is due to the sheer number of plans that are necessary otherwise. For instance, in a company with five shareholders, each individual requires four policies for each of the other shareholders. This can quickly lead to an unmanageable number of policies.

Own Life Under Business Trust

Each shareholder takes out life insurance on their own life for the value of their company shares.
They write the policy into trust for the benefit of the other shareholders.
In the event of a claim, the trust pays the funds to the remaining shareholders.
The most common method is for the company to pay. In this case, the company can typically deduct Shareholder Protection policy premiums as a business expense. However, shareholders generally pay income tax on the premiums, as these are a P11D / benefit in kind.
Sometimes each shareholder pays individually for their policy. In this case, they pay from post-tax income and there isn’t usually any further income tax for the individuals.
Regardless of who pays, as the insurer pays the lump sum benefit into a trust, there’s not usually tax for the business on the payout.

Company Share Purchase

The company takes out a policy on the life of each shareholder. The business therefore receives the lump sum benefit in the event of a claim.
Should a shareholder die or become critically ill, the company uses the funds to buy back and cancel the absent shareholder’s shares. This results in the proportionate shareholding of the remaining shareholders increasing.
In this case, HMRC does not typically consider premiums a business expense. That’s because they fail the ‘wholly and exclusively for the purposes of trade’ rule as the policy isn’t designed just to meet loss of profits caused by an outgoing shareholder’s death or illness.
However, as the company both pays the premiums and receives the payout, there aren’t usually tax implications for the individual shareholders.

Frequently Asked Questions...

How Does A Business Owner Value Their Company for Shareholder Protection?
Valuing a company for any reason, including for Shareholder Protection, can be tricky. There’s no tried and tested method of doing it. Moreover, each business differs, even within the same industry.

However, there are a few guidelines an adviser will use to help value your business when it comes to Shareholder Protection Insurance. For example, we’ll look at:
- Your company’s cashflow
- Your company’s profits, i.e. whether they’re static or increasing
- Multiples of net profit plus cash in bank and assets (better for companies with a solid, longstanding financial history)
- Intangible factors, for instance the company’s reputation and relationship with clients.
Ultimately, different industries / sectors often command different values, even if underlying business metrics are similar. As an independent insurance broker we have in-house experts who can provide advice in this area if you need help.
Is Shareholder Protection a Benefit in Kind / P11D?
Whether or not premiums are a P11D / benefit in kind for shareholders depends on how you set up the shareholder protection insurance policy. In brief:
- On a life of another basis — HMRC does not typically consider premiums a P11D benefit
- On a company share purchase basis — HMRC does not typically consider premiums a P11D benefit
- Own life under business trust — depends on whether the business pays or the individual pays, with HMRC considering it a P11D / benefit in kind where the business pays for the shareholders but not if the shareholder pays themselves.
Is Shareholder Protection Tax Deductible?
The tax position of Shareholder Protection Insurance depends on which of the three ways you choose to set it up.

In some cases premiums may be a tax deductible business expense against your corporation tax bill. This is common where the benefit passes the wholly and exclusively test, which means it’s entirely for the benefit of the business.

In this case, HMRC typically allows premiums as a business expense where the business pays for them.

However, if the benefit is not wholly and exclusively for the benefit of the business, such as where the payout benefits shareholders, HMRC usually does not consider premiums as a tax deductible business expense.

It’s a tricky area where it’s best to get expert advice.
What is a Cross Option Agreement?
You set up cross option agreements alongside Shareholder Insurance. It ensures that, if a shareholder dies, the other shareholders have the option to buy the deceased’s shares (the ‘call’ option). It also provides the option for the deceased’s family to sell (the ‘put’ option). This is also known as a double option agreement.

If a shareholder suffers a critical illness rather than passing away, only the put option exists. This gives the critically ill shareholder the option to sell their company shares to the other business owners but not the right for the business to buy the shares.

This protects a shareholder absent through illness from being forced out of the company and is also known as a single option agreement.

It’s essential that your company’s articles of association give each party the optionto buy / sell the shares, not an obligation. An obligation could result in an inheritance tax bill as it may disqualify the shares from business property relief (BPR). If in doubt, seek legal advice.
What is Shareholder Protection Premium Equalisation?
Where you choose an own life under business trust policy, you may need to equalise premiums if you and your fellow shareholders each pay the premiums yourselves.

For inheritance tax purposes this is to stop HMRC seeing unequal premiums as a ‘gift’ or ‘transfer of wealth’ to the shareholders paying the most to those paying the least. This might be, for instance, if one shareholder is notably older or has health problems and faces much higher premiums compared to younger, healthier counterparts.

If HMRC decides there has been such a gift, there could be inheritance tax implications in the event of a claim.

Who Are The Top UK Shareholder Protection Insurance Providers 2021?

As independent insurance brokers we work with all of the leading UK insurance providers. Below is a list of the major insurers we’ll get quotes from to achieve the most competitive terms:

AEGON
AIG
Aviva
Legal & General
Liverpool Victoria
Royal London
Scottish Widows
Vitality
Zurich.

Additional Policy Benefits

Most of the top insurers now provide a number of benefits alongside the core policy. These might include:

24 / 7 virtual GP service
Second medical opinion service
Counselling and stress helpline
Nutrition and fitness programs
High street discounts.

Compare Shareholder Protection Quotes & Get Expert Advice

When there are multiple shareholders with different holdings and various ways of structuring the protection it can start to get complicated quite quickly.

Fortunately, as an independent insurance broker we have a team of expert shareholder protection advisers on hand to make sure your cover is set up correctly with the best terms available.

Why Speak to Us?

We started Drewberry™ because we were tired of being treated like a number.

We know that our clients give so much to their businesses. They therefore deserve first class service when it comes protecting that business and their interest in it. Here are just a few reasons why it makes sense to talk to us:

There is no fee for our service
We are award winning 🏆 independent insurance advisers who work with all the leading UK insurers
You’ll speak to a dedicated expert from start to finish
We are very proud of the 3115 and growing independent client reviews rating us at 4.92 / 5
Claims support when you need it most.
We are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. You can find us on the financial services register here 🧐

For help and fee-free advice navigating the tricky world of business protection, don’t hesitate to get in touch. You can reach us on 02074425880 or email help@drewberry.co.uk.

Very good service from Rauri – he has been very helpful and thorough.

Kathryn Wright

16/05/2021

Read our 3115 independent reviews

Compare Top 10 UK Business Insurers

Takes approx. 60 seconds

Or call us on 0208 432 7333

Popular Shareholder Protection Guides

Who Are the Best UK Shareholder Protection Insurance Providers 2021?

A review of the best UK Shareholder Protection insurers in 2021. Read our expert review, get regulated advice and compare quotes from the best insurers...

How Much Does Shareholder Protection Cost In 2021?

If you are considering Shareholder Protection it is important to get an idea of how much it might cost? Use our calculator to get instant quotes from the top UK insurers...

What Is Shareholder Protection Premium Equalisation?

Guide detailing how Shareholder Protection Insurance premium equalisation works with real world examples and calculations.

Why Interface NRM Needed Shareholder Protection

Thriving UKAS-accredited certification firm Interface NRM has been running for almost two decades. Here's why Dr Gavin Jordan and his business partner decided it was time they got some valuable Shareholder Protection advice...

How Do I Value My Company Shares for Shareholder Protection Insurance?

How do I value my company shares for shareholder protection insurance? I want to ensure my family are able to realise the value of my shares...

Own Shares in a Business? How to Make Sure Your Family Benefits if You Pass Away…

Your business may be providing for you and your family today, but how do you ensure that it will continue to do so, even when you might no longer be around to run it? Fortunately, Shareholder Protection exists for this very reason...