Can I take out two income protection insurance plans?

I’m just about to take out some income cover but wondered if I can have two plans with two different income protection insurers? I essentially want to be able to cover 100% of my salary, is this possible?

Question asked by Vijay Kilbane
Compare Top 10 UK
 Protection
Insurers
 
Takes approx. 60 seconds
Type of Policy
Income Required
per
month
Date of Birth

Answered by Andrew Jenkinson

This is a very common question. Many people often make the mistake of over-insuring by taking out two income insurance plans in order to try and cover 100 percent of earnings.

Why only a percentage of income can be covered:

The issue is that insurers will only allow you to receive a certain proportion of your pre-incapacity earnings whilst out of work. Essentially, insurers do not want you to be just as well-off out of work as when you were in work, so there is always an incentive to go back to work.

Why two policies cannot be taken out:

The title to this section is a little misleading, you can take out two plans but just as long as the total level of cover doesn’t go over the maximum allowable for each insurer.

At claim stage an insurer will ask if you have any continuing income either from your job or any other insurance policies. If you have continuing income the insurer would reduce your level of cover so that you are not receiving more than the maximum they allow.

As an example, if you had two plans covering 50% of income and both insurers would only allow you to cover a maximum of 50% of income then only one plan would payout, the first plan you took out. The premiums you paid for the second plan would effectively have been wasted.

On the other hand, if you had only insured 25% of salary with each insurer (resulting in total cover of 50% of income) then there would be no issues at all.

So, how much can be covered?

Around half of income protection insurers will allow you to cover a maximum of 50% of your gross (taxable) earnings; however this does depend on your level of earnings as some insurers will allow a higher proportion for lower incomes.

Other insurers will allow you to cover up to 65% of earnings but it just means that the choice of insurers is very limited. It is important to note that the benefit paid out by personal income protection is tax-free.

More Info: How Much Can I Cover?

My earnings are low and I pay little tax

For some people who earn a low level of income it will be the case that gross and net earnings are very similar (given the personal tax allowance).

This can cause issues gaining enough cover as nearly all insurers base the level of cover on gross rather than net salary and often leads people think about trying to take out two income protection policies.

If this applies to you please pop us a call as there are a very small number of plans that do not take earnings into account, just so long as you’re working more than 16 hours per week. The Bills & Things plan by The Exeter is one such example.

maximum income protection
 
This information does not constitute financial or other professional advice. You should consult your professional adviser or contact us directly on 02084327333 should you require financial advice. It is important to ensure any insurance policy you take out is suitable for your needs.
Compare Top 10 UK Insurers
  Takes approx. 60 seconds
 - 
Need help? 
Call us on 

Frequently Asked Income Protection Insurance Questions

 
I’m considering taking out income protection, does this work in the same way as other types of...
 
I’m looking to take out income protection insurance and currently researching all the aspects of...
 
What is the difference between income protection insurance and payment protection? Which type of cover...
 
I have an existing income protection plan which I took out with my bank when I set-up my mortgage. I...
Need Help? Live chat now and get an instant answer from our Experts...

Neil
Pensions

Victoria
Insurance
Our Latest Reviews
Edward Brampton
13/01/2018

They were patient thorrgh and good value for money. I regret not using them before and I will use them again in the future.

Fiona Katumwa
11/01/2018

Very excellent service and informative. All options were offered and I had to make my own decision at the end. Would recommend.

Graham Mccollum
14/01/2018

Very efficient and well instructed service with polite staff, I felt Drewberry really did do their utmost to find the best deal for me personally.

We are rated 4.9/5 based on 1320 independent client reviews.
To read more of our independent client reviews click here →
REVIEWS
EXCELLENT
4.92 / 5 Average
1398 Reviews
A
Overall Rating
Very supportive and helped to choose effective product.
S Cutter
Overall Rating
Very professional and easy to deal with. Jake treated me like a human being and made me feel like a valued customer.
P
Overall Rating
Applied for an income protection plan and owing to medical condition had to make a few changes and Victoria from drewberry was really helpful
P Monaghan
Overall Rating
Courteous, prompt and clear service
D Lewis
Overall Rating
I was having trouble finding a suitable income protection policy online and was unclear about what I should be looking for, so I contacted Drewberry. The process was very quick and straightforward. They called me and explained how this type of insurance works, and then went through series of questions about my circumstances to try and find the right cover for me. They came back to me the next day with several suitable options and emailed all the relevant information clearly laid out. Michael Barrow, the advisor I spoke to, was happy to explain things in detail and answer any questions I had. I would definitely recommend Drewberry as they took all the hassle out of a confusing search.