Personal accident insurance or critical illness cover?

I’m currently researching insurances to cover me should i fall too ill to work, which is best personal accident or critical illness?


Question asked by Gemma Beachwood
Compare Top 10 UK
Takes approx. 60 seconds
Type of Policy
Level of Cover
Date of Birth
Loading your options...
Thank you for using our Quote Tool
If you need some help, just call us!
T: 0208 432 7333
Our in-house Experts are here to provide FREE impartial advice!
Our Experts can answer all your questions
Our Experts can send you more appropriate options based on your personal circumstances

Very important if you are either Self-Employed or a Company Director.

Our online quote tool is good but our Experts are better

Oue Experts have access to far more insurers and can often find a better deal offline.

Saves you time, let our Experts do what they are best at

Answered by Samantha Haffenden - Angear

Critical illness vs Personal Accident insurance

To start with, Drewberry would usually recommend critical illness insurance over personal accident insurance. The main reason being, Personal Accident Insurance is an inferior insurance product in comparison that covers you for major injuries specified in the policy documents, usually loss of limbs, major fracture injuries and other scenarios such as loss of sight to both eyes, loss of speech or loss of hearing. For which you would receive a small lump sum generally capped at £5,000 to £20,000.

Why Drewberry usually recommends Critical Illness cover

The main reason Drewberry would usually always recommend critical illness cover is because there are many comprehensive plans on the market which allow you to choose the conditions for which you want to be covered, some plans can cover over 170 illnesses and disabilities (personal accident plans often only cover serious injuries) and also pay out on a proportionate basis giving you the peace of mind that you will definitely get a payout relating to the seriousness of your injury.

Critical illness plans are medically underwritten at the point of inception so you know exactly what you are covered for from the outset. The sum assured can be a lot higher than the personal accident cover as it is up to you the amount you want to be covered. For example you may want to ensure the amount outstanding on your mortgage is covered.

critical illness insurance
personal accident insurance
This information does not constitute financial or other professional advice. You should consult your professional adviser or contact us directly on 02084327333 should you require financial advice. It is important to ensure any insurance policy you take out is suitable for your needs.
Compare Top 10 UK Insurers
  Takes approx. 60 seconds
Need help? 
Call us on 

Frequently Asked Critical Illness Insurance Questions

I’ve had a couple of medical conditions in the past and was wondering if i could still be eligible...
I go Skiing several times per year and wondered if this would be included if i’m to take out a...
I’m looking at taking out critical illness cover to pay off my mortgage should i be too ill to...
I’m 43 years old and looking at taking out critical illness cover. I drive a motorbike to work...
Need Help? Live chat now and get an instant answer from our Experts...


Our Latest Reviews
Andrew Giles

From start to finish a very professional and courteous outfit. A very efficient company with a no nonsense approach. Would recommend.

Mark Burbidge

First class service from start to finish. Sam Carr was very helpful in setting up my new insurance policies. He kept me up to date throughout the process and provided full explanation and advice on the products and was always available to help.

Doug Muirhead

Excellent personal service from Matthew Giles, made sure we received a tailor made quote that ideally suited our requirements as a family.

We are rated 4.9/5 based on 1512 independent client reviews.
To read more of our independent client reviews click here →
4.92 / 5 Average
1548 Reviews
R Steer
Overall Rating
Josh, Nick & Sam helped me set up PHI & Life insurance when I set up my own company. The application process wasn't straight forward due to my medical history, but the team made everything as simple as possible.
C Ash
Overall Rating
I have not started my health cover yet, bus so far the introduction has been very efficient and speedy.
G White
Overall Rating
Clear and concise information
D Muirhead
Overall Rating
Excellent personal service from Matthew Giles, made sure we received a tailor made quote that ideally suited our requirements as a family
S Walker
Overall Rating
Great service, independent advice, not pushy and very consultative. I would have no hesitation in recommending.