Income Protection Insurance Claim Payout Rates by Insurer

22/08/2022

Income Protection is designed to replace a proportion of your salary if you’re medically unable to work due to any illness or injury.

So long as the policyholder has selected a plan with an ‘Own Occupation’ incapacity definition the Income Protection policy will pay out if they are unable to undertake their current job role.

A claim will start once the policyholder has been unable to work for the length of their deferred period. The deferred period is chosen at the outset of the policy and often ranges from a week up to 6 months.

The successful payout rate for Income Protection insurers is high across the market, hopefully providing reassurance that these plans will pay out in the event that illness or injury means you can’t do your job.

Overall Protection Payout Rates Across All Insurers

Each year the Association of British Insurers (ABI) publishes average payout rate statistics from across all insurers. The latest figures are from 2021 and show that 86% of all Income Protection claims were paid, with over £688 million paid out in total.

From 2016, the Association of British Insurers is reporting Income Protection claims statistics differently. Previously, insurers included both ongoing and new claims in their payout rates and the sums they paid out each year.

Now only new claims are counted, which has affected the figures when you make a direct comparison to previous years,

Percentage of Income Protection Claims Paid by Insurer

The table below shows what proportion of income protection insurance claims were paid by each insurer (that published their payout rates).

As well as nearly every insurer sharing their claims payout data, certain providers now publish annual claims reports, providing detailed information on the common causes of claims, as well as reasons for rejections.

There is still a perception that these insurances don’t pay out, but fortunately the vast majority of claims are successful and provide an invaluable financial safety net for UK households.

Insurer

2020

2021

2022

Zurich

85%

99%

85%

Vitality

96.8%

N/A

96.5%

Shepherds Friendly

N/A

95%

96.2%

Cirencester Friendly

94%

93.6%

95.4%

Holloway Friendly

98%

94%

93.4%

British Friendly

87%

84%

90%

Liverpool Victoria

95%

93%

92%

The Exeter

91%

93%

92%

Aviva

87.5%

85.4%

94.3%

Legal & General

93%

81%

82.2%

IMPORTANT NOTICE
The above Income Protection Insurance payout statistics shouldn’t be used to make an exact comparison of insurers but rather to get a general understanding of payout rates across insurers as a whole.

Insurers use slightly different criteria for categorising declined claims; for example, some insurers might treat a fraudulent claim as declined, whereas others could have a different way of classing them.

Given this, the above table isn’t a simple measure of whether which insurer offers the best Income Protection Insurance. One insurer might have better policy wording or could be more suited to you. That’s why it’s helpful to get advice from someone who knows the market and providers inside out.

Need Advice Choosing The Best Income Protection?

When considering income protection insurance, above all you’ll want to ensure that your selected insurer will pay the benefit you’re entitled to in the event of a genuine claim, being there when you need the financial support the most.

However, on top of claims data you’ll also want to know that you’ve chosen the best Income Protection for you as an individual, including finding an insurer that will be most suitable for your circumstances such as your medical history and general health and lifestyle.

Why Speak to Us?

We started Drewberry™ because we were tired of being treated like a number.

We all deserve a first class service when it comes to issues as important as protecting our health and our finances. Below are just a few reasons why it makes sense to talk to us.

Read more!

Popular Income Protection Guides

What Is The UK's Best Income Protection Insurance In 2024?
Read our 2024 Best Income Protection Insurance UK Guide, get expert regulated advice and compare online quotes from Aviva, Vitality and other top UK insurers...
Income Protection Cost Calculator
Use our 2024 UK Income Protection Insurance Calculator to work out the level of cover you need and compare instant online quotes from Aviva, Legal & General, Vitality and other top UK insurers...
Income Protection or Critical Illness Insurance?
What is the difference between Income Protection and Critical Illness Insurance? Find out what policy best fits your personal situation...
Should I Get Index Linked Income Protection?
Should I get index linked income protection? Read our 2024 guide and find out why it can make sense to index link your policy to ensure your benefit is inflation proof should a claim arise...
Own, Suited or Any Occupation Income Protection?
Read our 2024 Own Occupation Income Protection Guide and find our about the other less desirable definitions, get expert advice and compare online quotes from Aviva, Vitality and other top UK insurers...
Setting Your Deferred Period With Income Protection
Everything about setting an Income Protection deferred period. How long should you wait for your benefit? Find the right deferment period for your needs.
Read more!