Drewberry™ provide pensions, investment and insurance advice for Money to the Masses readers throughout the UK.

 

Critical Illness Cover Claim Payout Rates by Insurer

This page should help to provide an indication of how good insurers are at paying Critical Illness Insurance claims. The claims statistics for Critical Illness Cover laid out below below cover the insurers we most commonly work the percentage of claims they’ve paid out over the last 3 years.

Critical Illness Cover is provide serious illness insurance, paying you a cash lump sum if you develop an insurer-specified critical illness.

Life and Critical Illness Insurance are often packaged together, but the below claims statistics cover standalone Critical Illness Insurance only.

Compare Top 10 UK
 Protection
Insurers
 
Takes approx. 60 seconds
Type of Policy
Level of Cover
Date of Birth
 

When Does Critical Illness Insurance Pay Out?

Critical Illness Insurance pays out a lump-sum to the policyholder should they suffer any of the illnesses listed in their policy, as long as the illness occurs during the term of the policy.

The average Critical Illness Insurance policy covers around 40 critical illnesses, but the number of conditions covered varies between providers from 35 to 170+. That’s why it’s valuable to get advice so you can ensure your policy has the broadest possible coverage.

The vast majority of claims are for cancers, heart attacks and strokes, although other commonly-covered serious illnesses include multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, kidney failure, motor neurone disease and permanent loss of vision/hearing.

Overall Protection Payout Rates Across All Insurers

Each year the Association of British Insurers (ABI) publishes average pay out rate statistics from across all insurers. The latest figures are from 2016 and show that 92.2% of all critical illness cover claims were paid, with over £1 billion getting paid out in total.

Need Help? Start Live Chat with our Experts  

Neil
Pensions Advice

Robert
Income Protection
 

Percentage of Critical Illness Claims paid out by Insurers

The table below shows what proportion of critical illness insurance claims were paid by each insurer (that published their payout rates).

Insurers
2014
2015
2016
Aegon
93%
97%
95%
Vitality Life
95%
93%
Legal & General
92.2%
91.5%
92.6%
Aviva
93.2%
92.5%
92.3%
AIG
91.4%
92.3%
Royal London
94%
93%
92.2%
Liverpool Victoria
88%
91%
92%
Friends Life
94%
93%
Note that Friends Life has now merged with and operates as part of Aviva.
 

Important Disclaimer

The above Critical Insurance payout statistics shouldn’t be used to make an exact comparison of insurers but rather to get a general understanding of payout rates across insurers as a whole.

Insurers use slightly different criteria for categorising declined claims; for example, some insurers might treat a fraudulent claim as declined, whereas others could have a different way of classing them.

Give this, the above table isn’t a simple measure of whether which insurer is best for Critical Illness Insurance – one insurer might have better policy wording or could be more suited to you. That’s why it’s helpful to get advice from someone who knows the market and providers inside out.

Victoria Slade
Independent Protection Expert at Drewberry

 

Insurer Claims Statistics

 

When choosing our personal protection we want to know it is going to pay out when we need it to.

By choosing a product or specific insurer from the menu below you will be able to view the claims payout rates for all of the main UK insurers for income protection, life insurance and critical illness insurance.

Insurer
2014
Percentage of Successful Claims
2015
Percentage of Successful Claims
2016
Percentage of Successful Claims
Critical Illness Insurance
Aegon
93%
97%
95%
Legal & General
92.2%
91.5%
92.6%
Aviva
93.2%
92.5%
92.3%
AIG
-
91.4%
92.3%
Royal London
94%
93%
92.2%
Liverpool Victoria
88%
91%
90%
Zurich
91%
92%
90%
Bright Grey
94%
-
-
Scottish Provident
94%
-
-
Friends Life
94%
93%
-
Income Protection
Holloway Friendly
96%
96.9%
98%
British Friendly
96.7%
97.8%
97%
Shepherds Friendly
96.7%
97.6%
97%
Royal London
90%
94%
95.6%
Legal & General
93.9%
95%
94.4%
Exeter
94%
94%
94%
Cirencester Friendly
94%
94%
94%
Vitality Life
-
-
94%
Aviva
93.2%
92.4%
92.6%
Liverpool Victoria
85%
92%
90%
Zurich
93%
87%
85%
Aegon
92%
85%
85%
Friends Life
86%
84%
-
Life Insurance
Scottish Widows
99%
98.9%
99.4%
Vitality Life
-
99%
99%
Aviva
99%
98.9%
98.9%
Legal & General
98.30%
97.9%
98.6%
Liverpool Victoria
98%
97%
98%
Zurich
99.8%
98.5%
98%
Aegon
98%
98%
98%
Royal London
98%
98%
96.8%
AIG
-
92.2%
95%
Friends Life
99%
99%
-
Expert insurance advice on finding the best Critical Illness Insurance provider

Need Advice on Choosing the Best Critical Illness Insurance?

When you take out Critical Illness Insurance, it’s obviously hugely important for you to be able to compare insurers and be sure that the provider will pay out in the event of a genuine claim.

However, you’ve also got to consider how to find the best Critical Illness Insurance given your circumstances, such as your health and lifestyle. Some insurers also offer additional benefits when you take out life cover with them – these can often be very good.

If you’re thinking about a critical illness policy, researching the insurers is a must to find the insurer with the best definitions of some of the more common illnesses.

Some will cover more illnesses than others, while others will simply have a more robust definition of that condition, increasing your likelihood of a successful claim. We can do all this research for you – just pop one of our advisers a call on 01273646484.

Rob Harvey
Independent Protection Expert at Drewberry

Compare Top 10 UK Insurers
  Takes approx. 60 seconds
 - 
Need help? 
Call us on 

Frequently Asked Critical Illness Insurance Questions

 
I’m thinking about taking our Critical Illness insurance for some time and have just taking our...
 
I’ve recently been declined critical illness insurance by an insurance company i have dealt with...
 
I’m looking to take out critical illness insurance to pay off my mortgage if i should fall ill....
 
I’ve recently had a heart attack and it’s really made me look at my finances. I would like...
REVIEWS
EXCELLENT
4.92 / 5 Average
1,263 Reviews
Anonymous
Overall Rating
SAM Carr was exceptional, he made my life very easy by explaining all the details very clearly whilst giving me the best advice possible for myself.

Would recommend to a friend!
Anonymous
Overall Rating
Provided the advice & guidance that I needed
M
Overall Rating
The overall experience which I have had can be summarized by Professional, Swift and friendly. I would recommend the service to others.
D
Overall Rating
Extremely helpful and rapid service at short notice.
A
Overall Rating
Very clear explanations of the options and then efficiently processed the transaction